Dr Anthony Fauci Once said, let coronavirus Transmission in order to achieve so-called herd immunity is an “unacceptable way” that will kill people.
National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (National Agency for International Development) The director’s comment, followed by Daily Beast Claims that the Trump administration is a policy based on this idea. The White House denied this request.
Top immunologist Fauci Asked to comment on the open letter to the emperor on animal immunity Barrington declaration, In a recent Q&A session with the editor Jama.
Traditionally, the term herd immunity describes the use of vaccines to protect enough people from infectious diseases so that they can no longer spread.
However, the term is Coronavirus disease-1
In the exchange video released on Wednesday, Fauci Said: “Do you know how many people will die before you get there? This is an unacceptable way. We get immunity from vaccines, and this is how you damage immunity. Not everyone is infected,” he said. Fauci.
avoid locking Protecting the disadvantaged is like motherhood and apple pie, Fauci Said.However, it is estimated that 70% to 75% of the population will need access to coronavirus He added that in order to achieve herd immunity.
Fauci It also emphasized the difficulty of protecting vulnerable groups.He said conservative estimates indicate that more than 30% of the US population is Coronavirus disease-19 Complications, because they have underlying diseases such as diabetes, obesity, hypertension or chronic kidney disease, or because they are older.
According to the Kaiser Family Foundation non-profit organization, among adults over the age of 18, four in ten adults (37.6%) have a higher risk of serious illness Coronavirus disease-19, a total of 92.6 million people.
of National Agency for International Development The director said that it might be possible to block those people in the nursing home, but he asked, “How will you protect people in society?” Fauci Say: “For kindness liqueur Take a look at the data. “
His concerns echo those of Dr. Mike Ryan, Executive Director of the World Health Organization (WHO) Emergency Medical Program. He said on Monday that since the outbreak of the pandemic, protecting vulnerable groups has been the main goal of WHO. But this is difficult because “the vast majority of vulnerable groups among them We in a multi-generational family. “
Earlier this month, the Director-General of WHO Tedros Adhanom Gibriasus Also warn against letting the virus spread unrestricted, Part of the reason is that people who were previously healthy suffer from “long-term Coronavirus disease. “
Dr Jay BatachariaIs a professor of medicine at Stanford University and co-authored Barrington Declare, tell Weekly newspaper: “Doctor Fauci It is completely wrong. His comments reflect a failure to think creatively about how to protect people at risk from the virus. ”
Batacharia Said locking “Obviously failing to protect the disadvantaged Coronavirus diseaseThere are many unnecessary deaths in nursing homes, and older “basic” workers are forced to choose between supporting their families and risking exposure to the virus. ”
He said that the lockdown has caused people to die from conditions unrelated to COVID-19, and said that the implementation of these measures “will lead to more deaths and human suffering in the short and medium term than focused protection strategies.”
White House Strategy
FauciComments followed by Daily Beast The report cited three unnamed senior health officials for working with the White House coronavirus The task force claimed that President Donald Trump and his consultant The concept of group immunity has been accepted and used as the basis for policy.
The website reported that Trump administration officials cited Barrington The declaration said in a recent phone call with reporters that “protecting the disadvantaged” is its focus, because “most people do very well.”
Fauci Recently claimed that the President has not yet met with the White House coronavirus Task force, where Fauci Is a member because “Months.”
Sarah Matthews, deputy secretary of the White House, told Weekly newspaper: “The President regularly receives relevant coronavirus every day. Information about major decisions will be brought to him, and then he will move forward in the way that best suits our country. “
Dr. Scott Atlas, coronavirus According to reports, the White House consultant has no expertise in infectious diseases or epidemiology, and he has pushed the concept of herd immunity to the Trump administration. Atlas has repeatedly denied this claim.
A health official who asked not to be named told reporters: “This is the entire atlas.” Daily Beast. “I found it disturbing… ridiculous. Almost everything coming out of Atlas’ mouth was to make it rip, and then worry about protecting the vulnerable.”
Trump stated in ABC News that this concept appeared to be mentioned in September. town Hall: “You will develop […] Like a group of people […] The herd is developed, this will happen. “
The next day, the press secretary Kelly McKenney At the press conference, he said: “There has never been a strategy of ethnic immunity here in the White House. The President pointed out last night that ethnic immunity has been used for some time.”
McKenney He also denied that Atlas had proposed herd immunization as a strategy.
Dr. Scott Atlas told Weekly newspaper Thursday: “The goal is to protect as many people as possible from the destructive effects of the virus and HIV locking. As we have clearly stated many times in our records and prints, we strongly deny that the White House, the President, the government or anyone who advises the President adopts or advocates a broad strategy in pursuit of herd immunity, which is to let the infection proceed through the community. The president was never advised to do this, and it was never part of any of the president’s policies. “
This article has been updated with comments from the White House, Dr. Scott Atlas and Professor Jay Batacharia.